Wednesday, November 19, 2008

Reading introduction and questions for consideration (11/20 Readings)

Lots of readings today basically trying to give insight into the ways foreign policy changes in the 1990s with the end of the Cold War. Here’s a short intro of each:


1) Excerpts from the Pentagon’s Plan, “Prevent the Re-Emergence of a New Rival”: This is a section of a Pentagon document leaked to The New York Times in March 1992 seeking to outline the goals of the Department of Defense over the years 1994 to 1999. The full document was written in February 1992 largely by Paul Wolfowitz who at the time was the undersecretary of defense for policy (the Pentagon’s third-highest ranking official) in the George H.W. Bush administration. Wolfowitz, of course, would later become the Deputy Secretary of Defense in Georg W. Bush’s first term. Think about the goals of the document and how the end of the Cold War figures into the foreign policy it advocates. Also note that after being released to the public, there was a massive outcry from foreign policy makers and ex-military which caused the first Bush to order the document re-written. Think about this as you read as well.


2) Stedman, “The New Interventionists”: An essay from the 1992/1993 Foreign Affairs (an elite foreign policy journal) articulating where the author sees post-Cold War foreign policy heading.


3) Kristol/Kagan, “Toward a New Reaganite Foreign Policy”: Written in the July/August 1996 Foreign Affairs by two leading neoconservatives as they are trying to articulate and push their post-Cold War foreign policy doctrine. In particular, this is targeted at Bob Dole’s 1996 presidential campaign. The authors try to use a history of Reagan’s presidency from which to argue their foreign policy. Compare their history to my interpretation in last class as well as to the next article by Holmes and Hillen.


4) Holmes/Hillen, “Misreading Reagan’s Legacy”: A response to the Kristol/Kagan piece by two conservatives who are not a fan of their neoconservatism. They argue that the two misread Reagan’s legacy and are essentially not conservatives. They do this to put forth their more limited post-Cold War foreign policy. In both of these essays also try and think of the way in which both are arguing against Clinton’s foreign policy as well.


5) Bush/Scowcroft, “Why We Didn’t Remove Saddam,”: A 1998 essay in Time where the first president Bush and one of his top advisors Brent Scowcroft argue why they did not remove Saddam Hussein at the end of the first Gulf War (1990-1991). They are writing this in large measure because of neoconservatives like Kristol who are now out in public arguing it was a mistake to leave Hussein in power.



1 comment:

Anonymous said...

In the article by Kristol and Kagan, there is a brief mention of Kissinger and his cohorts clashing with Reagan on foreign policies. As a figurehead of foreign diplomacy for years, I imagine Kissinger still had quite a bit of influence in the conservative core. How easy was it for Reagan to persuade this following? Was the outcome of Vietnam used against Kissinger's policies?