The introduction to Melani McAlister’s Epic Encounters contains eight sections. For today, we want to make sure we understand all of these sections and the role they play in the development of McAlister’s argument. The eight sections (with pages numbers) are as follows:
Middle East Interests (1-4)
Moral Geographies and the Cultural Field (4-8)
Orientalism and Beyond (8-12)
The Middle East as “
Shopping the Orient (20-29)
Expanding Interests (29-35)
Defining the
Contested Encounters (39-42)
Your group of 3 is assigned the bolded section of the intro. For your section, answer the following questions:
- What role does this section play in the development of McAlister’s argument? What is the intellectual work of the section?
- Are there particular passages or sentences in your section which you think are key to understanding both the section and its role in the overall introduction? Why?
In your group decide which person is going to take the following roles:
1. writing down your thoughts on this paper
2. writing down your thoughts on the board
3. typing your thoughts into the comments section on the blog
For each of these roles, do not feel as if you have to write in complete paragraphs. Feel free to write using notations, sentences, outlines, whatever works best for understanding the section and seeking to articulate its meaning.
Finally, even if your role is not to write on the blog, you should feel free to add to our discussion online. NOTE: If you are writing the blog comment for your group, be sure to include the names of all group members in your comment as this will count towards participation.
16 comments:
Our group was assigned Shopping the Orient (20-29). McAlister argues that the United States became interested in the Orient for economic and spiritual pursuits. During a major economic depression from 1893 to 1897 the United States suffered from overproduction among other problems and was searching for new markets. (20) It was also during this time that Americans and Europeans became fascinated with the occult. (21) American consumerism took over and people turned to the Orient. McAlister writes: "Harem scenes, Japanese gardens, Persian carpets and fabric, stores decorated as mosques or desert oases: the Orient was everywhere in these consumer stagings." (21) She argues that all of these goods carried a sexual undertone. Women during this time came more into public life and this all coincided with the first feminist movement. A key passage in this section is on page 22: "Orientalism was the cultural logic through which American culture symbolized a break from nineteenth-century Protestant piety and marked the nation's entry into 'modernity.'" She later argues that this consumerism turns the orient into a commodity with books, films, and even King Tut himself.
Mike, Thomas, Tom
Group members:
Eric Brown
Greg Schwab
Paul Schenck
Moral Geographies and the Cultural Field.
In this section, McAlister deals mostly with the theoretical framework through which she argues the rest of the book. The concept of "Moral Geography" is that of identity making of the 'self' and of the 'other'. She adopts the term from Michael Shapiro. She talks about forming the construction of American identity based on its différance to the 'other', in this case, the purpose of the book is dealing with the construction of the 'Middle East' and how it influenced both American identity and foreign policy. McAlister points to the a quote by David Campbell which she sums up to the effect that the existence of the state is dependent on a "sense of danger"[pg. 6] and that it is through the threat of the 'other' that identity (in this case national) is held together. McAlister also goes into an explanation of her analysis of the cultural component of foreign relations, positing an intertextual relationship between culture and foreign relations saying that "in order to understand the political import of culture requires that we place cultural texts in history"[pg. 5] and that "the cultural field exists in continuous relationship with other fields within the larger social system." [pg. 7] An idea she takes from the French Sociologist Pierre Bourdieu. This is the 'cultural field' that makes up the second part of the section heading. The conclusion of the section includes a pronouncement of what one of her central theses is: "...cultural productions help make meanings by their historical association with other meaning-making activity"[pg. 8]
Group Members: Andrew Niles, Thomas Gengler, Tria Vang
Expanding Interests (29-35)
In this section, McAlister summarizes earlier U.S. foreign interventions to put the interaction with the Middle East in context. She uses the colonial aspiration of the Philippines and the annexation of Puerto Rico and Guam as an example for this. With the U.S. beginning to look elsewhere for economic investments, the interests of the middle east was at a high from earlier media and cultural perception of the region; this then opens the door for the U.S to expand its interest and leads into McAlister's argument that strategic positioning, religious ties, support for Israel, and access to oil were the four primary interests of the U.S. in the Middle East. A key passage to this section is this: "In the years before World War II, U.S. state policy and U.S. businesses converged to promote the economic influence of U.S. based corporations as an alternative to conquest," (pg. 30). This quote introduces the idea of "dollar diplomacy" in which it can obviously be seen as the answer to the question leading into, "why these four interest?"
Our group dealt with the Shopping the Orient section of the introduction. The group members were Brian Anderson, Amy Weiby, and Gillian Spence.
On page 27 McAlister sums up her argument of popular culture shaping and transforming the Orient, "The Orient, like the Holy Land, was linked to spectacle, though the meaning of spectacle itself had changed, from its nineteenth-century associations with religious and scientific knowledge to turn-of-the-century links to fraternity, consumerism, and loosened sexuality."
McAlister ties consumerism to sexuality on page 21 and 22.
There was also a breakdown of gender spheres and Protestant piety, as well as cultural products that define the American Identity an allow America to exercise power. Themes of sexuality and sensuality brought women into the public sphere and marketplace.
Orientalism and Beyond
Tom Malik, Tim G. Charles N.
McAlister presents a general representation of Edward Said’s 1978 analysis Orientalism and describes it, as everything “East” is the Orient, including varying nations from China to Saudi Arabia. Said describes European desires for the Orient as exotic and mysterious, thus provoking the idea of Femininity and its attraction towards Europeans and that these preconceived ideas of culture and art laid the foundation for “Imperial Rule.” McAlister describes it as a European model that the U.S. has adapted since the end of World War II. The European model presented colonial ideas such as, the East being feminine, removed from the industrial society, stresses, being a haven of tranquility and thus colonial Eastern people got no vote and exclusion form democratic rights. During the post World War II years, the U.S. would break these types of stigma to fracture European logic and install a new framework and that the difference between European Orientalism and American Orientalism was that the European model was used all the time, while the American model was used sporadically when they saw fit to it.
The Kyle's and Amanda
Our group was assigned the section on Orientalism and beyond. McAlister agreed with the premise of Orientalism to advance her argument. She said that Orientalism contributes to the idea of imperialism and that along with this idea a binary has been formed. The binary being that there is a general way in which that part of the world is seen. For instance America and European nations are thought to be masculine and civilized, while the Oriental nations are seen as feminine and disorganized. Having said that, there is an overall confusion of gender with one another.
A passage that we say fitting was "Putting Orientalism in its place, then, becomes part of the analytical to historical task at hand."
Will M, Nicholas O, and Bryan K
Middle East Interests (1-4)
We thought of this section as an introduction to the introduction. McAlister begins by arguing that the Middle East "was not immediately...an American interest...had to be made interesting" through two primary avenues: 1- oil and 2- religious origins (made interesting to the public through cultural forces like Biblical epics and the King Tut exhibit). These interests were inextricably intertwined with the cold war and lead to two dueling policies in U.S. foreign relations with the Middle East 1- Distancing, othering, and containme and 2- Affiliation, appropriation, and co-optation.
Group Members:
Laura Thomas
Lauren Cork
Claire Campbell
Our group's section was Contested Encounters (39-42).
In this section, McAlister summarizes her overall argument and previews the chapters. Her book "analyzes the importance of representations of the Middle East in the construction of postwar U.S. nationalism and the contest over the meaning of 'Americanness'" (39).
-the U.S. positioned itself as different from old colonial powers
-shift from European power/imperialism to "benevolent supremacy," U.S. dominant (Middle East subordinate), but by choice (unlike old imperialism)
-"political and cultural conditions" lead to a "post-Orientalist model of representing the Middle East for American audiences" (40)
Evan
Mikki
Kristin
Our group analyzed Contested Encounters (39-42).
McAlister uses this section to present her thesis in the book: that convergences, cultural and political, between America and the Middle East construct meaning to explain foreign policy influence on domestic culture in the US. She oulines the progression of her argument through a summary of the chapters and the topic of her argument in each. (Road map).
Important passages:
-struggles over the construction of meaning of the Middle East
-"changing cultural logic of US foreign policy"
-influence of forieng affairs in domestic culture
I forgot to include her Intellectual work, which includes:
-"Post-Orientalism" as a study of post WWII conditions in US
-noting the evidence she will refer to in coming chapters
Sorry this is so late... had some internet troubles
Rob Thompson
Amanda B
Sam
This section of the introduction was literally and introduction to the introduction. McAlister argues that the presence of oil in the Middle East, and the claim to religious origins perpetuate interest in the Middle East. These two interests (oil and religion) prompted two different types of policies toward the Middle East in the Cold War. First was a policy of distancing, containment, and othering. The second was affiliation, appropriation, and co-option. These policies are reflected in chronological times. Pre Bush41 (H.W. Bush) the United States distanced, contained, and otherized the Middle East where was during Bush’s presidency, our foreign policy toward the Middle East reflected the second policy type. McAlister then goes on to suggest that popular culture (like movies, etc) formed representation of the Middle East that continues to be used to stereotype the region today.
also that was the first section "Middle East Interests" or whatever.
Also had some internet difficulties here, sorry.
We had section 7, titled "Defining the Middle East and Its People". In this section, the author lays the groundwork for the post-Orientalism argument by challenging Said's claim that the United States had simply continued the Orientalist views held by the previous dominant world powers in Europe. She does this with the following points:
1) The academic world found that peoples in the Middle East could not be lumped together into one general category, as all countries and cultures in the region were very diverse from each other. This was a result of the development of area studies. Middle Eastern studies became its own academic field in 1967.
2) The immigration of arab peoples to the United States underwent changes that reinforce the author's argument as well. In 1909, US courts found that a Syrian was no different that someone from east Asia, but in the 1940s, courts found differently, granting them caucasian status. This emphasizes the author's point that it was Americans that were defining the race and culture of Middle Eastern peoples, not the people themselves.
Forgot to post the names in the group....
Tyler Erickson
Matt Postevco
James Conrad
Lee Chriske
Eric DeVoe
Expanding Interests (29-35)
This section sets up the framework through which McAlister will analyze the manifestations of Middle East-American encounters:
1. Cold War alliance building
2. "The Holy Land," i.e. Religion
3. Israel
4. Oil
This framework works to explore the emergence of a "new imperialism" of American hegemony after 1945: "American strategy of commerical expansion rather than territorial control" (31). It places the United States in the unusual position of fighting the Soviet Union with European alliances WHILE fighting European dominance through anti-colonialism; asserting an unchallenged American global dominance by subverting Soviet and European dominance. McAlister cites the coming of "new imperialism" in America through domestic elites--Mark Twain, W.E.B. DuBois, Etc.--further emphasizing the foreign-domestic inseparability of U.S. policy.
McAlister claims that media, especially the film industry from Hollywood, was the key role in changing from direct control to cultural management of countries. "Trade follow the film," she cites and quotes a rephrased saying "The sun never sets on the British Empire and the American motion picture" (31). This presents and justifies her claim that media and film play an important role in post-WWII policy and deserve scholarly attention.
Sam, Keri, Annie
McAlister uses Michel Shapiro's term moral geographies, to denote a geography with borders based on thoughts and ideas. McAlister states, "The nation-state is modernity's most powerful moral geography."(pg.6) Stemming from that statement, and realizing the significance nations hold today, McAlister discusses how foreign policy is one of the most common ways in which a nation ‘speaks’ and thus its importance to the framing of moral geographies. After establishing this importance, McCalister also makes a point to tell the reader how the nation state can succeed, and that is through “a sense of danger and instability.” (pg.6) All of this information is going to help make sense as to why the study of the foreign relations between the United States and Middle-East is important. The next chunk of this section discusses what a cultural field is. McAlister importantly tells the reader how textual analysis is merely a first step, and textual analysis is not enough. Instead it is through reading these items intertextually and distinguishing the way in which the text connects with other political discourses that one can uses these items in an argument in which they are politically significant. Also discussed in this section is the idea that mass media is an independent discourse able to support or dispute national policy and or foreign goals for “The apparent ‘statement’ of a text, then, is not the same as its historically constituted meaning.” (pg. 8)
Post a Comment