Prompt for Essay #2: 15% of final grade for course
FOR THIS ESSAY, YOU WILL CHOOSE EITHER OPTION #1 OR OPTION #2
OPTION #1: Argumentative Essay
REQUIREMENTS:
Length: A typed paper between 1200 and 1800 words.
Source material: All course material (readings, lecture, lecture sources, documentaries, etc.) from the September 30 class through the November 13 class
Due: Beginning of November 18th class.
It is important that your essay be entirely your own work, so please do not discuss the questions or your essay with anyone in the class. Please consult only with Jason if you have concerns and/or questions. Remember, I will look at first page drafts (see syllabus for more info), so be sure to take advantage of this opportunity.
The purpose of this assignment is to create a historical argument of your own. There are no right or wrong answers to these questions, only well-defended and poorly defended arguments. To make sure that you write a well-defended essay, first be certain that you assert a clear argumentative thesis (i.e. a position with which someone might disagree, but which you can prove to be correct). Second, make sure you offer lots of corroborating evidence. Imagine a reader who is deeply suspicious of your point of view, and then try to build an argument that will persuade even this skeptic. The most persuasive evidence is detailed and drawn from a variety of sources. This evidence will not simply be inserted and allowed to “speak for itself.” Rather, you will analyze the textual evidence in order to specifically detail how it helps to prove your argument. Finally, feel free to build on and cite the arguments I have made in class as well as the arguments of the historians you have read. However, do not repeat the arguments as your own. Engage with them only as they relate to the argument you are making.
On Source Citation: Use footnotes (these don’t count towards your word limit). I don’t really care about format, so long as the source of your quote or paraphrase is clear through the footnote. For reader documents just make sure I know the author, document, and reader page number of the particular quote cited. For lecture, date and lecture title is fine. For sources linked within lectures, this will most likely involve the website and a naming of the source. Ask me if you have any questions about this, but please to not obsess over this or other formatting issues.
QUESTIONS TO CONSIDER FOR OPTION #1:
Remember, I am looking for a coherent persuasive argument which incorporates evidence from the class. Moreover, the argument should be broad enough to give you room to apply specific evidence from the reading, but specific enough to avoid an argument which is too simplistic. In each of these essays, questions are given not so you can click off answers to them in your essay but rather to stimulate your thinking towards developing an argument of your own. DO NOT feel the need to answer all questions in your essay. I merely provide a number of questions under each essay in order to get you thinking about possible arguments you can put forward. Also DO NOT feel as if your argument and evidence needs to encompass the entire chronological period we have discussed thus far. Finally, feel free to combine the themes of multiple numbers into your argument. Note: You will see below that many of the questions are same to those asked in your last long essay. If you feel comfortable with a particular theme you dealt with last time, you should feel free to continue to develop that line of inquiry.
1) A theme we have returned to throughout the second third of this course is how the United States was able to transition from World War II to the Cold War in such a short period of time—especially given that the Soviets were allied with the U.S. in World War II. What were the most important factors in this transition? How was this transition accomplished at both the domestic and international levels?
2) In the second third of our course, we have looked at many sources which have discussed the use of popular culture in the construction of
3) In the second third of our course, we have discussed the Cold War construction of “The Third World.” How, why, and in what terms did
4) A theme we have continued to deal with throughout the second third of the course is the way in which history has often been invoked as a way to take a particular action internationally. In what ways has the production of historical narrative been used to further foreign policies? In what ways has the production of historical narrative been used to argue against certain foreign policies? What does such production say about the nature of memory? What does such production say about the role of the historian in foreign policy? How can the notion of the “end” of a particular historical period lead to new international actions?
5) A theme we have returned to throughout the second third of our course is the role of elite “experts” in the making of foreign relations. What has been the primary role of “the expert” in making foreign policy? Besides academic expertise what other types of expertise have been marshaled in support of
6) Have you been thinking a lot about something else that is not captured by one of these questions? Would you rather write an essay that explores your own idea? If so, then develop an argument of your own for this essay. If you choose this option, be sure to discuss your essay in advance with Jason.
OPTION #2: Book Review
REQUIREMENTS:
Length: A typed review between 1200 and 1800 words.
Source material: Melani McAlister’s Epic Encounters
Due: Beginning of November 18th class.
In this part of our course, you are reading the prefaces, the introduction, chapter 1, and chapters 3 through 5 of Melani McAlister’s Epic Encounters: Culture, Media, &
Guidelines for the review:
Although I discuss the review in terms of “sections” do not actually have section headings. Instead, write your review as a cohesive whole which transitions from section to section using the topic sentences of paragraphs, not section headings.
In the first section, identify the argument of the book. Why do you think the author is writing? What, specifically, is the argument she is attempting to convey? In the second section summarize the book. What do its chapters contain? How is it organized? What historical evidence does the author use to support the argument? How do the chapters flow from the argument McAlister is making? In the third section analyze the strengths and weaknesses of the book. Where does it fall short? What is particularly persuasive? What is missing? Finally, in the fourth section, place the book within the context of the course. How does the book fit with the lectures and discussions? What does it add to our understanding of the construction of American history? What documents or articles are in conversation with McAlister and in what ways?
Writing a good book review is extremely challenging and will require a considerable amount of reflection on your part. You will find that taking notes, marking your text while reading, and participating in class discussion over the book will greatly help you to write a good review. Finally, please do not be tempted to read published reviews of the book. Boyd and I have read them all and plagiarism will result in and “F” for the assignment.