Monday, October 27, 2008

Reading introduction and questions for consideration (10/28 Readings)

1) Senate Debate of the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution: A brief excerpt from the Senate debate over the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution which would lead to the massive escalation of the war in Vietnam. The resolution passed unanimously in the House of Representatives and with only two dissenting votes in the Senate (Mr. Gruening and Mr. Morse).

  • What are the contours of the debate over presidential power in this excerpt?


2) LBJ, “Peace without Conquest”: Shortly after winning the 1964 presidential election in a landslide, Johnson gave this famous speech outlining his Vietnam policy and giving his rationale for the war. At the point he gives the speech, 400 U.S. soldiers had died in the war. On his leaving office in early 1969, some 35,000 more have been added to the death toll.

  • What is Johnson’s justification for the war? How does his justification compare to others we’ve read by presidents in the past?
  • Once again, in what ways does Johnson construct American history as justification for his policy?
  • How can we see his rhetoric engaging in the idea of “modernization” as described by Rostow?


3) Nixon address to the nation, 11/3/1969: Given a year after Nixon wins election to his first term, this is an outline of his Vietnam policy and his case for maintaining U.S. involvement in the region.

  • What is Nixon’s justification to continuing the war? How does it compare and contrast to LBJ’s as outlined in the first speech?
  • What is the “silent majority” as outlined by Nixon? How does this “majority” play into his argument for continuing the war? How does he characterize opposition to the war?


4) Nixon, “Peace with Honor”: The speech Nixon gives after a negotiated settlement for the end of the war. American combat troops would be fully gone two months later although all American personnel would not leave until mid-1975.

No comments: