Tuesday, September 9, 2008

Interpreting "Act I" of In-Class Documentary

Today we are watching “Act I” of the historical documentary Crucible of Empire: The Spanish-American War. As you watch, I want you to try and think about the genre of the historical documentary. As with the other secondary sources in this class, we want to think of it not as a passive rendering of “what happened,” but rather a particular interpretation of the period which needs our evaluation a historians. So, as you watch, take notes and think about the following:


1) What interpretation(s) does “Act I” put forward as to why the U.S. made an “imperial turn” at the end of the 19th/beginning of the 20th centuries?


2) Where are the interpretations of “Act I” in agreement with Bederman’s interpretation of this shift from last week? Where do the interpretations of “Act I” differ from last week?


3) This about your primary source evidence that you read for today? How does this evidence support and/or undermine the interpretations of “Act I.”?


10 comments:

Thomas Braun said...

Hey Jason -
Are you willing to read drafts of Thursday's short response paper?

Jason said...

Yes, I will look at drafts of the first paragraph of short writing responses.

Anonymous said...

Tuesday (9/9) in class another student asked if the Monroe Doctrine was used as a justification for the Spanish-American War.

Doesn't the Monroe Doctrine pertain only to NEW attempts at European intervention in the Western Hemisphere? Isn't this why the US got upset with France trying to take Mexico in the 1860's? And why the US did NOT intervene in the Falklands War in the early 1980's, since the British were there before the Monroe Doctrine?

Or can politicians easily ignore the Doctrine? Could they have ignored it in 1898?

Jason said...

Andrew is absolutely right here and I'm not sure why I spaced on this in class.

The Monroe Doctrine -- as I said in our second class -- was to prevent any new European colonization in the Western Hemisphere. There was no new colonization in Cuba, so it would not have made sense to use the Doctrine as a rationale for invading.

Further, as Andrew correctly points out, in all cases presidential doctrines are nearly always selectively interpreted -- that is, they are applied in some cases and not others.

I'll be sure to clear this up in class on Thursday.

Thanks Andrew!

Thomas Braun said...

That is what the Monroe Doctrine's original intention was. However, over the course of the 19th century many presidents and cabinet members (Grant, Cleveland, Olney) changed the interpretation of the Doctrine. Eventually, TR himself amended it when he added the Roosevelt Corollary. Presidents later used the Roosevelt Corollary as justification for U.S. intervention in several other countries, including Cuba in 1906. Now, I know that this is after the Spanish-American War, but the reason I brought up the Monroe Doctrine during class was not for justification of that war, but U.S. policy as a whole.

Jason said...

Thomas,

Very good here. Although I was definitely aware of the Roosevelt Corollary, I am far less knowledgeable of the 19th c. changes you cite. Do you have info on what these changes were exactly? No worries if not, I was just curious.

Jason

Thomas Braun said...

Sure thing. President Grant extended the Monroe Doctrine to say that European powers could not hand over colonies to each other in treaties. President Cleveland and his secretary of state, Richard Olney, extended it to say that the U.S. had the right to intervene in border disputes.
After the 19th century some changes were made as well. The Clark Memorandum of 1928 argued that the U.S. had an inherent right to intervene in Latin America and did not even need the Monroe Doctrine. That memorandum was later rescinded by FDR's Good Neighbor policy but came back into vogue during the Cold War to argue against Soviet involvement in the affairs of Latin American countries.

Greg said...

From our readings, I could see that the S-A War, like every war, provoked inspiration and emotion in both artists and politicians.
In reading Kipling's poem and Twain's short story, we could see the war from their artistic viewpoints, wryly critical of the government. Then, reading the articles by TR, Lodge, and Beveridge, we were able to see that same issue in a completely different way - from the eyes of a politician.
By doing the readings first, we were able to go into the documentary with some prior knowledge of the differing perspectives of the war at the turn of the 19th century.

Annie said...

I think Gregory brings up a good point although I also think that the viewpoints in the articles from TR, Lodge and Beveridge although all in a similar perspective all frame arguments and justifications for the war quite differently. While TR argued for the creation of a greater civilization one in which the United States needed to constantly prove the country's masculinity, Lodge talked about how the United States could be a mediator, and like Act I(although not quite as blatantly as the documentary) seemed to hint as to how the war would make our nation a heroic nation. Beveridge however, frames his justifications and reasoning quite differently when talking openly about the nation's economic gain, it is interesting that although this was probably on the minds of the other writers/politicians as well they fail to give it much if any significance.

ptschenck said...

I found it interesting that the video was prefaced with talk about the closing of the American Frontier. It was implying, at least how I read it, that the United States' economy was completely geared toward colonization and needed a constant territorial expansion to increase resources for extraction. It reminds me of the concept of the military-industrial complex.